The Resistance Brief: This week in the fight for justice 

Why the courts still matter

Blog by Ricardo Martinez (he/him), Executive Director

I know we are all feeling the weight of the strain that our democracy is currently under. In these moments, I try to remember what I learned about our government’s system of checks and balances. Our three-branch government is supposed to divide power amongst each part to prevent tyranny.   

And while the current administration may have gone into an Executive Order-issuing frenzy causing confusion, panic, and disorder, there remain built-in limits to what the president can do through executive action alone. This is certainly the case when politics are working business as usual. JD Vance’s most recent comments about the courts not being able to tell the executive branch what to do signal a concerning willingness to defy judicial review. But the courts must remain a backstop against unconstitutional actions. And we, the people, have a role to play in ensuring the courts exercise their rightful role – and enforce executive compliance. It is paramount we do not succumb to apathy; lives are at stake.  

Court decisions can impact our everyday lives. In the case of Maria Moe, an incarcerated transgender woman and client of GLAD Law, it was court intervention that prevented her from facing the imminent danger that would have come from being moved to a men’s facility and having her necessary medical care taken away. 

Court decisions can delay the implementation of discriminatory laws that pass at the state or federal level. In the case of Parker Tirrell, a district court judge blocked the enforcement of a recently passed New Hampshire state law, HB 1205, which prevented Parker from playing soccer with her friends. Earlier this week, GLAD Law and our partners at ACLU of New Hampshire expanded our case to include a legal challenge to President Trump’s executive orders that ban transgender girls and women from sports nationwide. 

Using the courts to delay dangerous policies is harm-reduction. It’s also strategically advantageous – it buys us time to allow the community to develop contingency plans and mutual aid networks, allows us and other advocacy organizations to educate targeted communities about their rights, and provides more time for state-level protections to be enacted where possible. And it can allow time for the democratic process, and those charged with safeguarding it, to reassert a commitment to civil rights. 

Ultimately, courts can stop unconstitutional policies and reaffirm that equal protection applies to everyone, without exception. 

This doesn’t mean that the courts are our only avenue for resistance. It is critical for advocacy organizations and individuals to use every channel we have to disrupt and reject the abject treatment of fellow Americans we are experiencing under this presidency – whether it be through acts of peaceful protest, calls to elected representatives, or engaging in the deeply important local battles being fought in towns big and small throughout this country.   

It’s going to take uncommon courage: faith leaders asking the President to show mercy for those in harm’s way, women in STEM preserving their stories and achievements, a Super Bowl halftime show strategically agitating the masses. We need outspoken lawmakers stepping outside of their calculus for reelection and leaning into values of equality and justice, and more unapologetic corporate tenacity the likes of Costco.  

If we are going to protect our civil rights and democracy, and turn away from tyranny, we need the courts, and we need all of us. We must swing big; it’s the only way to shift our collective consciousness. 

What to know, what to do:  

Donate Today

Read more editions of the Resistance Brief.